Ed Harding transform our approach to cardiovascular disease?

Ed Harding

How can a prevention mindset transform our approach to cardiovascular disease?

1 March 2023

How can a prevention mindset transform our approach to cardiovascular disease?

To mark the launch of a new national consensus paper on the future of cardiovascular health in Ireland, we reflect on the value of prevention in cardiovascular care.

Why do we need a prevention approach in cardiovascular disease (CVD), and how is it different from ordinary care? Ask any of the 85 million people in Europe who are living with CVD, who often struggle to get the care and support they need to avoid further acute events and admissions.

Last year, we were invited to work with leading Irish stakeholders to help them develop a new vision for a national cardiovascular plan. Inspired by this project, I have been reflecting on the value of prevention in cardiovascular health and how this mindset must be brought across the whole patient journey, not only in Ireland but across Europe.

 

The urgent need for a new approach to cardiovascular care

Governments have traditionally allocated most healthcare spend to the short-term management of acute events, such as heart attacks and strokes, with hospitals providing much of the care. Yet as noted by the Irish Health Service Executive, this approach is ‘neither patient-centred nor sustainable’, a verdict that is relevant to most other high-income countries as well. In fact, across OECD countries, less than 3% of healthcare spending is allocated to preventive services and programmes. Considering that many more people than before are surviving a heart attack or stroke, and that 25–30% of strokes occur in people who have had a previous stroke, such level of underinvestment has a tangible impact on our budgets and societies.

To an extent, Western governments understand the need to prevent non-communicable diseases. Many have launched national public health programmes with a range of measures to support healthy living, such as reducing intake of fat, salt and sugar, further reducing smoking and helping people exercise and lose weight. Yet as fundamental as these behavioural and environmental drivers are, we must be honest about the likelihood of public health measures alone being successful in dealing with these giants and their consequences.

Many have launched national public health programmes with a range of measures to support healthy living, such as reducing intake of fat, salt and sugar, further reducing smoking and helping people exercise and lose weight.

 

The opportunities for the prevention mindset

What is the answer? In short, our mindset in prevention must evolve. We must design health systems to ensure the prevention of the next heart attack, stroke or heart failure hospital admission, just as much as they work to ensure the person survives the event itself and can be safely discharged. We will need to offer focused, longer-term support to those who need it, while we simultaneously try to redesign our environment to promote health for all.

The good news is that we have proven models to prevent repeat cardiac events in the highest-risk groups. Multi-component prevention programmes can reduce cardiovascular mortality by 58%; they can lower the chance of a repeat heart attack by 30% and of a repeat stroke by 60%. In heart failure, disease management programmes can reduce disease progression and resulting hospital admissions by as much as 30%.

 

What needs to happen to turn the prevention ambition into reality?

To integrate CVD prevention into everyday lives is to align it with people’s own goals and aspirations for quality of life. We need to understand that the window of opportunity to prevent, delay or mitigate CVD evolves with the individual, and this includes more intensive efforts in higher-needs populations. Achieving this vision would require several expectations of healthcare, including those below, which feature in the Irish CVD prevention paper:

  • CVD prevention should be initiated immediately in hospital after major events.
  • People who have had a cardiovascular event must be referred to community-based prevention programmes, and followed up to ensure they engage with these programmes.
  • Primary care clinicians must be supported to identify people at risk and manage their conditions more effectively, starting with targeted and opportunistic screening for higher-needs individuals.
  • Expanding the roles of nurses and allied health professionals could support more ambitious person-centred care.
  • Better data on post-acute care are needed, as what gets measured gets done.
How can a prevention mindset transform our approach to cardiovascular disease?

To integrate CVD prevention into everyday lives is to align it with people’s own goals and aspirations for quality of life.

 

What next for cardiovascular health? Ireland can lead the way

It is our strong hope the Irish government will now lead a new, prevention-focused plan for cardiovascular health. This would be an exciting and influential move at home and abroad; healthcare decision-making is often conservative, in the main driven by an acute-focused, short-term, cost-containment mindset. And if Ireland did adopt this model, it could also be a promising case study to inspire other countries.

But convincing governments to follow the prevention mindset may not be straightforward. It requires a fundamental discussion as to what healthcare spend is for, and what return on investment can be expected. This would suggest an obvious role for the European Union (EU) in advancing the common strategic investments and optimal solutions in this field, for example by coordinating research, innovation and best-practice learning.

This would be very timely. At the EU level, cardiovascular advocates are raising their voice to demand an equivalent plan in cardiovascular health to the current Europe’s Beating Cancer Plan. But they need Member States to support this. Ireland has led Europe before in its ambitious health policy goals, such as the plain tobacco packaging directive – might Dublin just be tempted to take this fine tradition forward to its next logical phase? That would be good news for everyone.

Read the Irish national position paper: Advancing a prevention agenda for cardiovascular care in Ireland.

 

The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of The Health Policy Partnership.
Share